I’ve heard people advise businesses to “Go out and pinpoint what you like about competitors’ (or even non-competitors’) branding and marketing content and duplicate their tactics as part of their marketing strategies. It’s not all bad advice. Seeing what your competitors are doing is critical to figuring out how to differentiate your brand. And looking to your favorite brands for inspiration is also a good idea. However, when it comes to flat out imitating another business, we disagree entirely.
Every business should tailor its marketing strategy and ensure that it is truly unique to their business, rather than relying on industry “best” practices or the latest marketing trends. That’s why one of our mottos here at Gray Matter Marketing is “Strategy Over Tactics.”
Instead of going off a checklist of tactics or throwing a bunch of tactics at the wall and hoping something sticks,
we create a custom marketing plan
based specifically on your needs, audience, resources, budget, and goals.
Maybe you’re not convinced yet. After all, if another business, specifically a competitor, has success, shouldn’t you? Unfortunately, the answer is a resounding “No,” and here’s why:
No two businesses are alike
Even if you and your competitors sell the near-exact product or service to the exact same people (which is highly unlikely), your businesses are still supremely different. Your culture and people, your relationships with the marketplace, your internal resources (i.e., budget, tech, and staff), and the assets you’ve developed will vary widely.
Before you compare yourself to everyone else and try to copy their marketing approaches, remember:
- If your business is brand new, you likely don’t have the email database or social media followers of a more established business, so digital marketing may not work the way it does with your competition.
- If you are a startup or small business, chances are you don’t have the budget to compete with a larger or established brand in the same capacity. You simply can’t do what they’re doing—but that’s not even the best reason to skip the imitation tactics.
How you interact with your customers may be different
Wendy’s restaurant is notorious for being savage on Twitter, particularly when it comes to
dragging major competitor McDonald’s. And the slang, sarcasm, and pithiness appear to work for them. They have millions of followers and decent engagement. Still, try that approach with an older, more conservative customer base, and that tactic will backfire big time.
Gain a clear understanding of who your customers are, their expectations and challenges, and how they like to consume information. Then go where they are. For example, if they’re more likely to read blogs, write blogs, but if they are big consumers of social media, invest there. While you don’t want to rely on just one strategy (i.e., email), it’s not necessary to have a presence on every social media platform or use every channel out there.
Our best advice: Start small, ensure that you can maintain the consistency and frequency of whatever it is you do, whether that is posting to Twitter or blogging, and then grow from there. Be sure to monitor the results of anything you do. If something isn’t gaining any traction, let it go so you can focus on tasks and projects that generate results. And don’t be afraid to ask your current customers (and don’t forget your sales force) how they want to receive information and tweak your tactics and marketing dollars on this information.
You need to understand and communicate your differentiators
People are inundated with messages, so you want to stand out from the rest. That means showcasing how you are different, and being unique, not mimicking what someone else is doing. So, if anything, look to competitors for what to do differently or better, not for what you want to adopt.
If you have a value proposition (your promise to your customers about how you will provide them with a value differently from everyone else), you may want to revisit it once a year and determine if it’s still viable based on the competitive landscape. If you don’t have a solid pitch, I’d recommend developing one ASAP.
So, imitation is out – now what?
Build a custom strategy tailored to the specific needs of your business and your customers. If you want to develop your brand identity and build a marketing strategy that will help you reach profitability faster, we can help. Learn about our services
here.